What is synthesis writing?
Synthesis writing is a craft. The writer writes. The AI assists.
In synthesis writing, the writer owns the experience, position, and voice of the work. AI may help draft or revise the expression of a position the writer has formed. The writer checks the claims, chooses the final words, and accepts responsibility for them. Writers can also choose to work without AI.
Drafting help begins with a position the writer has formed and material the writer supplies. The writer decides what stays, revises what misses the point, and takes responsibility for the final work.
Think of synthesis writing as the craft of working at a new kind of writer's desk in the long history of writing tools. Your dictionary, your grammar guide, your fact-checker, and your proofreader are within reach. The pen in your hand can draw on them as you write, suggesting a cleaner phrase, catching a typo, cross-referencing a fact, reformatting a piece for a different audience. The pen is not a writer. The desk is not a writer. Neither ever was. Neither ever will be.
Principles
- The writer is the author. Always. The substance, the voice, the judgment, and the meaning are human, full stop.
- The writer directs the work. AI may help with research, factual checks, critique, drafting and revision. The writer decides the position, meaning, voice and final words.
- A choice, not an imperative. Writers who never use AI are practicing the craft just as legitimately. Synthesis writing is one form among many.
- Transparency. Be honest about AI's involvement — as this site is, and as Anthropic's own writing guidance urges.
- Elevate craft, not efficiency. Depth and quality. Never speed and cost.
- Not a product. Synthesis writing is a craft and a discipline. Not any particular tool, platform, or software.
A craft worth teaching
The long-term ambition is for synthesis writing to become a subject taught in schools and universities, refined over time as composition, rhetoric and journalism have been. Better tools should help writers deepen their craft: develop judgment, preserve a distinctive voice and produce work worth reading. The discipline belongs to writers and their practice, independent of any particular product.
Review a claim against its evidence
The Slopcheck editorial example begins with an invented sentence:
Our new review process has dramatically improved the quality of our work and made collaboration more effective.
The sentence claims an improvement but gives no comparison. Changing “dramatically” to a quieter word would leave the same missing evidence.
A useful reviewer asks what changed. Was another reviewer added? Did the process catch an error before publication? What comparison supports the claimed improvement? The surrounding draft or source notes may already answer those questions; read them before treating the omission as a defect.
| What the available material establishes | What the writer can responsibly do |
|---|---|
| A documented change and a relevant comparison | Describe the change and the result within that comparison’s limits. |
| A change was made, but its effect has not been assessed | Describe the change and its intended purpose. |
| No source for either the change or its result | Obtain the missing reporting or remove the unsupported claim. |
An assistant must not invent a metric, an incident or a success story to fill the gap. The writer can perform this review with source notes and a pen, with a colleague or with an automated reviewer.
Preserve what makes the passage work
A proposed edit needs a reader benefit. Before accepting it, compare the original and suggestion: does the revision retain the example, qualification, humor or turn of phrase that carried the meaning? Plain language can be exactly right. A list or familiar expression is not a defect merely because it appears in a pattern catalog.
Ask for the exact passage, the problem it creates and the source supporting the proposed change. Leave purposeful prose alone when the criticism does not hold up. A stylistic resemblance does not establish who wrote the draft or which tool they used.
For a factual review, this request keeps the task concrete:
Read this paragraph with the supplied source notes. Identify claims the notes support, contradict or do not establish. Quote any claim that needs checking and name the source that would resolve it. Preserve useful detail and voice. Do not infer authorship or invent missing facts.
Writing resources
- Using Slopcheck to review a draft examines a criticism before accepting its edit.
- AI Content Quality: An Open-Source Framework for Writing That Doesn't Read Like AI (2025) introduces the framework’s pattern catalog and editing prompts.
- The content-quality instructions supply editorial questions; fact-checking instructions address claims, quotations and attribution. Use the questions to inspect the writing, without treating pattern ratings as authorship evidence.
Follow the writing feed or browse the archive. Rajiv Pant wrote the linked guides and examples. Editors and writers can contribute a correction or a better example, including a case where a proposed rule would erase something valuable. Use passages you have permission to share.